Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Wild West Part 1

I'm back from my western fishing trip. I came back sick as a dog (I left with a chest cold, and it didn't improve.... flying back and changing planes just nailed me. A week later and my ears are still stuffed up). Despite feeling only about 80-90% the whole time, the fishing and experiences (along with massive doses of Vitamin C) kept me going.

I fished 3 places: 1) Black Canyon of the Gunnison; 2) the Rio Grande near South Fork; and 3) the Valles Calderas in the Jemez Mountains of NM.

GUNNISON

The Black Canyon is one of the most remote canyons in the US. Now a National Park, it is a "wilderness area", which means no motors and nothing left behind. We did a 2 night, 2.5 day drift, camping each night. Most of the fishing was from the rafts: You'd pop a cast into likely looking pockets near the bank - with a hopper/dropper combination. The closer to the bank the better. Sometimes a fish would take your fly.... most medium size 11-14", a few bigger, 16"+, and, every once and a while, a monster. The Gunnison, due to whirling disease, is now almost exclusively a brown trout fishery (it used to be dominantly rainbows). The few 'bows that survive were adults when whirling disease hit, are 7+ years old, and are now enormous.

At times, we'd get out of the boats and fish from the banks.

"Chuck and chance" fishing isn't normally my favorite. But the need for precision casting redeemed it somewhat: you often flashed by these pockets as you drifted by. And it seems that if you could hit the edge water in the more remote, harder to reach pockets, you had the best chance to catch a nice fish. So it was fast and furious: spot a hole, shoot a cast next to the bank, watch for a strike, pull off as you flew by on the drift, spot another hole, cast... all in a continual rhythm. It was fun but tiring... I'm not used to casting 100 times/hour, but that's what this was.



I caught a lot of fish... mostly fat and feisty 12" browns. A 16" brown emerged from the bank about my 4th cast on the first day, giving me a mistaken notion of how easy the fishing would be. The rest of the day disabused me of this notion, as it was the largest fish I would catch that day.

The morning of the second day I hooked into an enormous rainbow in a smallish pocket, just as we entered a riffle. Normally, when you hook a fish, even a pretty big one, they follow the boat with the current. But not this guy. He headed upstream as we went down. I was 20' into my backing when he broke off, just as the guide was able to stop the raft in a back eddy. I had a good look at the fish when he struck... it had deep maroon flanks, the color of dried blood, and was not only long, but tall and broad. I suspect it would have rivaled the largest trout I've ever caught, had I landed him. But it was not to be. Probably the biggest fish I landed was a 19" brown on the afternoon of the second day.

The fishing died in the middle of the day with direct sunlight. So we'd fish from 10 to 12 in the morning, and 4-7 in the afternoons. A smaller group might have started earlier, but we had to break camp in the morning, and I was the sole outsider with a family group of 5.




A somewhat nicer than average Gunnison Brown.





Loading the boats in the morning after camping. John, the other fisherman in the group, is standing, holding the 5 gallon water jug (John's family paddled along...there were some rather nice rapids). Bill, our guide, is standing in the water. Kevin is helping load the boat. Once underway, I was usually standing in the bow, braced against the aluminum tubing. All the crap in the boat was constantly snagging line, which was a frequent annoyance.

Bottom line is it's a wonderful fishery, and a recommended experience. If I were to do it again, I'd go with a friend and do it as a 2-day, one night trip. As it turned out, the last day was almost a complete bust anyway, as it was late and bright sun most of the time. The trick would be to rise early: if you could do 8-12 on the second day, take a siesta, and then finish 4-7 or so you could have a great experience with only one night of camping.

SOUTH FORK

South Fork seems like a throwback to the Colorado of the 1970s. There are only two restaurants in town (neither very good, though the "Hungry Logger" served a mean Hoevos Rancheros for breakfast, which forgives almost everything else). I met up there with Todd Bowen, who organizes my annual bonefishing pilgrimage to Punta Allen, and John Holtcamp, a friend of Todd's whom I've met briefly in Mexico. Todd went missing the first day, traveling to a junk yard to secure parts for his truck, and John and I drifted the Rio Grande with a guide.

The flows in the Rio Grande had just dropped the day before from about 1,600 cfs to under 1,000 cfs, which unsettles the fish. The morning (through early afternoon) was absolutely brutal. John and I each caught only two fish, having worked our butts off. We started with hopper/dropper fishing the banks (just like on the Gunnison). This is normally killer on the Rio, but neither of us had any luck. John picked up a fish rising to a yellow sally hatch, fishing from the bank, and I caught one on a deep nymph, holding behind a rock. We tried deep nymphing from the boat (nothing), streamers (picked up one nice fish in the first 5 minutes, then nothing more for over an hour). But for several hours there was nothing. Nothing. Nothing.

After lunch, I went back to hopper/dropper, and started fishing the very last foam line against the bank. A couple of fish seemed to flash on the fly, so I was encourage to keep going. Finally, about 2:30, a 15" brown sneaked out from a rock wall and took my dropper. Then, for the next 90 minutes of so, as long as I kept my cast aggressively, and dangerously, close to the bank, I had pretty good action, catching 6 or so fish, and raising a bunch more, almost all browns.

At the end of the day, the guide announced we were in "Lunker Lane", a place where big rainbows tended to hold, and he spotted one rising underneath the balcony of a house built right on the bank of the river. John was in the front of the boat, and put in a nice cast which it took....



A lovely fish, which redeemed the day for both of us.

The next day, John, Todd, and I fished the South Fork... catching small browns rising to tiny caddis emergers. It was good fun. Around noon, the hatch ended, and I hopped into the car for a 4 hour drive to Jemez Springs.

Wild West Part 2

VALLES CALDERAS

The Valles Calderas is a National Preserve in northern NM, in the Jemez Mountains not far from Los Alamos. It was an original Spanish land grant, operated as a ranch continually from the early 19th century, until it was bought by the Federal Government in the 1980s. There are a number of streams on the property, which are tightly regulated to manage fishing pressure. You have to make a reservation and pay a $35 rod fee.

On a good day, the fishing is outstanding. Day 1, I fished the East Fork of the Jemez. See image below.


If you can't see the stream, don't feel bad. It's what it's like. The stream is that dark squiggle towards the right side of the image, and and you can just see (in the darker curves) how it meanders through the middle of the image. Here, the average width is only 18" or so, and it's often nearly hidden by the grass, even when you're on top of it. Every now and then, typically at a bend, it broadens out a bit, and that's where you can cast.

Fishing was dominated by the fact that it's been a very dry July in NM, and all of the streams in the Valles Caldera were running low. On the Jemez, it meant that you saw very few fish. Normally, when the fishing is good, the fish hold on top of the weed beds. (The Jemez fishes like a spring creek with ranunculus weeds covering much of the bottom. There's a good 18" of water BELOW the weeds, and when the water is high, a good 6" or more on top). Normally, when you come to a decent-sized opening, you can see 6, 8, or 10 fish on top of the weeds. They're spooky, you have to put in a good cast, but it's all sight fishing. They're not particularly selective (a hopper almost always works), so if you can get in a good cast, you can catch fish.

On THIS DAY, I saw only one fish all day that I actually cast to, and it was holding in a pocket above the true bottom, not above the weeds. I did see a trout burrow down through the weeds. But I didn't see a single trout holding on top - I think the water was just too low.

The only way I could figure out to catch fish was to spy an opening from a distance (the fish are really spooky, so you can't get a good look). If I saw a patch of light brown, it suggested there was a bit of bottom showing. Often, this patch was very small, maybe a 18" square within an opening that wasn't all that big to begin with...perhaps 2' by 4'. From about 30' I needed to drop a hopper onto the patch on the first cast (miss the cast, and the hopper would invariably snag on the grass... the commotion of retrieving it would spook any fish; get closer, and you'd spook the fish).

If I did everything right, most of the time I was rewarded with a strike. So I wasn't casting to fish (except in the one case I mentioned where I saw the trout above the patch). I was casting to patches of bottom.

It took me about 90 minutes minutes to figure this out. Another 30 minutes to adjust my casting to the appropriate accuracy. Luckily, I found myself in a "zone" for about 90 minutes, and in that period I managed a dozen strikes or so, and landed 6 fish. Five were rainbows. The smallest was probably 10" and the biggest 13". The sixth fish was a 10" chub. After that, while it took me a couple of hours to admit it, I was exhausted (did I mention I'd walked about 3 miles over this hummocky grass?). I walked downstream another mile and a half to get to "bigger water", but was so exhausted by the time got there, that I couldn't focus on the fishing, and wasn't catching anything. Then thunderstorms threatened, and I pretty much gave up after that.

I met a fisherman the next day who'd fished the East Fork several times in prior years, with good success, and had fished it that day, catching only 2 chub. So I guess I did OK. He was pissed.

The next two days I fished the San Antonio. The image below is from Reach 3 (of 4), which I fished Saturday. This is pretty typical of the size of the water, and is relatively "big" for the San Antonio. Only reach 4 has bigger water. Reach 1 (which I fished Sunday) is about half the average width you see here, though it does broaden into pools at least this wide in places.




While spring fed, the San Antonio fishes a lot more like a freestone stream, and has structure with riffles, pockets, undercuts, etc.

There are a LOT of fish on this stream. If you could get a fly drifting on water with any depth (anywhere) you would almost certainly get a strike, as long as you hadn't spooked the fish. And that was the rub. With the water so low, the fish were insanely spooky.

As you can see, there's basically no cover. You had to approach the stream bent over, rod tip down, and as you got closer, crawling on your elbows and knees. Sometimes you could take advantage of a tuft of taller grass, or bank erosion to provide a little extra cover. Once in position, you could carefully peer over the grass at the structure, and cast from a seated or kneeling stance. I don't think I ever caught fish if I was closer than 20' from where I was casting. And 30' was a lot better. With the 3 wt rod I was using, and a light breeze, it was constantly challenging, especially as the low position meant your backcast could snag on grass or thistles if you weren't careful.

As long as you didn't "line" fish, you could cast two or three times before spooking everything. However, generally you didn't need to cast more than once. Fish would swim well off their lie to snag your fly (they were delighted with my #12 hopper). However, you'd only get one take per structure. Whether you got a refusal, a strike, or hooked a fish, every other fish in the structure was spooked after that. They were very good at wriggling off the hook, frequently leaping, and diving into the weeds.

I hooked probably 30 fish, and landed 15ish, all but one browns (one 'bow). Most were 11-12". Large was perhaps 13". Judging from comments in the shuttle bus coming back from the stream, that was a whole lot better than most other folks did. Two fishermen admitted to catching two fish all day each. A couple of others just looked glum.

Sunday I asked for Reach 1, on the theory that the narrower banks would restrict the vision of the fish more and make them easier to approach. That turned out to be the case. While I did have to be careful, and cast from at least 20 feet, I never had to crawl into position (stooped over was OK), and half the time I could cast from a standing position. I was into fish all day. I never really counted, but it had to be 30+. Average size was smaller than on Reach 3. Typical was 9"-10". Maybe a third were 11"-12".

Overall, I had fun on the San Antonio. I'm sure that when the fishing is "on" this can be an easy river. Several anglers I spoke to recounted catching fish "on every cast" in other trips, and I believe it given the number if fish I saw. My fear going in was that this would be too easy. In the final analysis, I was fully challenged on the San Antonio. On the Jemez, it was totally challenging, but I can't say it was fun. Next time I'll try May.