In Gravity's Rainbow, Pynchon describes paranoia: "If the bastards get you to ask the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about their answers." Well, today, in Harriman, I never felt I was asking the right questions.
Perhaps it was my late start. I'd intended to head off around 7, but June didn't get home last night until around 2 AM, and when I woke this morning, I turned over to get a few more winks rather than hopping into the car. In the event, I didn't get onto the stream until nearly noon.
Perhaps it was the heat. "Low 80s" became mid 80s. Making my late start even more problematic.
Perhaps it was my desire to explore more of the river. I decided to skip all of the water I'd fished last week, and to explore the upper reaches. While it wasn't obvious when I started, it was painfully obvious when I walked out that the best structures were in middle reaches of the stream, which I'd mostly skipped.
I did see a few large fish, in the first couple of structures I fished. The water was low, quiet, and absolutely clear. My first few casts spooked fish. You could see a school of fish (mostly small dace, but with a few much larger shapes - obviously trout - mixed in). They would scatter below my approaching line, then coalesce back to the center after it landed.
Then I lengthened my leader to about 14', which, on a small stream with small structures, made for challenging casts. At least then I could cover a couple of nice fish without obviously spooking them, but they showed absolutely no interest in my dry flies.
My best shot at a nice fish was in large pocket, shortly after lengthening my leader. The brown trout looked to be 14" or 15". I could see it very clearly, holding comfortably in a V shaped slot between two boulders, in the gentle current. The water was crystal clear, with almost no turbulence.
I crept up as close as I dared, about 25' behind him. My only shot, as I saw it, was to launch a long cast (45' or so) to the very head of the pocket, to get my fly high into the current lane, and hope it would drift my fly through the slot. Too low, and it would catch the current braid passing the wrong side of the right hand boulder.
I felt this was one of those casts which had to be right the first time. With fish this spooky, your odds of catching go down about 90% with each cast.
In the event, I got off what I thought was a perfect cast, but my fly didn't drift. Unfortunately, it had snagged some brush right at the head of the pocket. The cast couldn't have been more than an inch or two long. As soon as I pulled on my fly line - still gently I thought - the taught line pulled out of the water and the fish spotted it. Spooked, it shot back towards me, then saw me, turned instantly and shot upstream past my line into the next pocket.
That was my last real shot, though I spent another 4 hours in denial. After that, I didn't see another nice fish (for possible reasons, see above).
I did catch a lot of fish. One pumpkinseed, and a ton of Dace. No trout.
At least I was challenged. For 5 hours. I am nothing if not persistent. No regrets.
Wednesday, June 02, 2010
Saturday, May 29, 2010
Memorial Day Reflections
I always have mixed feelings about Memorial Day. On the one hand, NJ wild trout fishing is usually close to peak (I think the early stone fly hatch in mid April is the only better time). On the other hand, you know that hot weather and diminished fishing is coming soon. With the weather forecast for the high 80s tomorrow, and 90 degrees on Monday, I was anxious to get out today.
I headed for T creek, my closest brook trout stream, leaving earlyish so I could be home for a real estate appointment at 3 PM.
Arriving at the stream a little before 11 AM, I tied on my "default" #16 adams, walked down to the stream, and cast into the first nice pocket I saw. It was bowl-shaped, supported just enough flow to create some turbulence, and was mid-calf at the deepest point. On my third cast, a truly lovely fish shot up to take my fly. It was a fat, 11" brookie, one of the nicest fish you'll find on this stream. Unfortunately, my camera didn't work (I hadn't seated the battery properly), so I didn't get a shot. The picture below, taken after I'd sorted out the battery, is of a smaller fish, landed a few minutes later, a good inch or two shorter than the first one.
So while the first fish was perhaps the fish of the day (possibly equaled by a fish landed a couple of hours later), today was one of those magical NJ wild trout days when you're constantly catching fish. Find the right structure (the very first was the archetype), cover it with a nice drift, and you were almost certainly going to raise a fish. I don't remember a single refusal, except ones caused by drag in my presentation (and few of those). One anxious 7" brookie swam off its line by about 3 feet to take my fly, slowly drifting in a foam line.
The largest fish turned out to be holding in the mid-sized pockets, like the first structure I had fished. The bigger pockets would also hold fish - sometime five or six - but the biggest fish seemed to prefer a mid sized pocket all to themselves. As it was, I must have landed 25 to 30 fish within 2 hours. 10 from two big pockets (roughly 5 each, mostly small), and then another 15 or 20 in 1's and 2's from other structures.
I stopped around 1, to head back for my appointment. It had been enough.
I headed for T creek, my closest brook trout stream, leaving earlyish so I could be home for a real estate appointment at 3 PM.
Arriving at the stream a little before 11 AM, I tied on my "default" #16 adams, walked down to the stream, and cast into the first nice pocket I saw. It was bowl-shaped, supported just enough flow to create some turbulence, and was mid-calf at the deepest point. On my third cast, a truly lovely fish shot up to take my fly. It was a fat, 11" brookie, one of the nicest fish you'll find on this stream. Unfortunately, my camera didn't work (I hadn't seated the battery properly), so I didn't get a shot. The picture below, taken after I'd sorted out the battery, is of a smaller fish, landed a few minutes later, a good inch or two shorter than the first one.
So while the first fish was perhaps the fish of the day (possibly equaled by a fish landed a couple of hours later), today was one of those magical NJ wild trout days when you're constantly catching fish. Find the right structure (the very first was the archetype), cover it with a nice drift, and you were almost certainly going to raise a fish. I don't remember a single refusal, except ones caused by drag in my presentation (and few of those). One anxious 7" brookie swam off its line by about 3 feet to take my fly, slowly drifting in a foam line.
The largest fish turned out to be holding in the mid-sized pockets, like the first structure I had fished. The bigger pockets would also hold fish - sometime five or six - but the biggest fish seemed to prefer a mid sized pocket all to themselves. As it was, I must have landed 25 to 30 fish within 2 hours. 10 from two big pockets (roughly 5 each, mostly small), and then another 15 or 20 in 1's and 2's from other structures.
I stopped around 1, to head back for my appointment. It had been enough.
Wednesday, May 26, 2010
Harriman
Exploring new water is always a tough thing to justify. The local streams are so close and reliable, you know the new stream is going to give you a worse outing. Dan and I sure experienced that last weekend. On the other hand, the local streams are so reliable, and by now I know them so well, that there's not a lot of challenge to them.
Last week I bought a season NY State license, so it freed me to do something I've been meaning to do for years, which is explore Harriman State Park. I've hiked it several times, perhaps 15 years ago, but never fished it. It's just over the border, and time-wise, it's about 1:45 from Trenton, about the same as driving up to Van Campens. I'd heard there were some nice streams there. So I went online, and found really very little, except a 5 year old posting on a fly fishing board from a guy who claimed to live up there, who listed two of his favorite streams.
I found them both on a map. One really wasn't my style: it had road access its entire length. The other required a hike in, and ran through an isolated valley. Perfect! It had the added benefit of being in the far south of the park, making it even closer. Yeah! So today, after my appointment in Princeton this morning, I headed up 206 instead of coming home, and found myself at the trailhead around 1.
The stream was steep, and held a fair amount of water. I walked in about 30 minutes, then started to fish the pocket water. It reminded me of T Brook, only with about twice the flow.
Unfortunately, no fish. I tried a bunch of flies... started with a Cahill. Switched to a BHPT. After about an hour I landed a 3" green dace. An hour later, I picked an inchworm off my hat, and switched to an inchworm dry fly. But nothing.
I was about 3 hours in, with still only the dace in the credit column. I was thinking of giving up, when I came to the junction of a major trib... the junction pool didn't look like much, but just above the junction, the gradient of the main stem eased noticeably. I tossed the inchworm into the very first pocket above the junction, and was stunned when a feisty, 10" brown trout slammed the fly. I was actually startled by how strong he was. He pulled upstream about 20 feet, and I gave line for fear he'd break my 6x tippet. Very cool. This trout wasn't a giant, but would count as a big fish on any of NJ streams I normally frequent.
(Below: The first fish. You can see the inchworm fly in his mouth)
Why the steam below the trib didn't seem to hold any trout, I don't know. Perhaps it floods too frequently. All I know is it started to act like a lovely trout stream as soon as I got above it. (Below, the stream, just above where I caught the first fish)
It didn't take long for me to take a second fish... this one another strong, wild brown trout. This turned out to be a solid, fat 12". He also slammed the inchworm. He was holding in the quiet water, just right of the medium sized round rock in the middle/left of the photo.
I then tried to work may way up the slow pool you see in the photo, and around the bend. The inchworm was now waterlogged, kept sinking, and snagging bottom. So I spent about half an hour trying not to spook fish as I slowly waded in to free my fly, cast again, snagged again. All the movement killed the fishing. So I changed to a #14 parachute adams, which I figured would float reliably.
After making my way up to the next big pool, I took an even LARGER fish, a good 13", on the adams. When he felt the hook, he shot into the air about 3', then spun around the pool at a high rate of speed until he exhausted himself. On my light little 4 weight, it was all I could do to keep him under control and away from some snags.
Once I released him, I farted around this pool for a while, trying long casts, double hauling my little rod (which is NOT its preferred casting mode). However, the water was so still that any movement towards the back was sure to spook any fish waiting for me. I missed one strike from what flashed like another big fish, then caught a little pumkinseed. Then things seemed to go dead.
According to the topo map, there's probably another mile of good water, but the shadows were getting long. I reeled up, and started to hike back to the car. I saw some rising fish in a large pool close to the parking lot, where the gradient had eased again. I hovered for about two minutes, watching the water, and debating whether to give them a shot. Had I seen another rise, I might have been tempted, but it went quiet for the moment. I decided it was getting too late, and hurried on to the trailhead parking lot.
It was 6:05 by the time I stripped off my gear and started the car.
All in all, while it started slowly, it ended totally satisfactorily. Next time, I'll hike right above the junction, and start fishing from there. Judging from my sample, the fish in this stream are much larger than any wild trout stream I know in NJ. Definitely worth a return visit. Of course, it's also the sort of water where you'll be miserable if you're fishing behind anyone. One fisherman, even a good one, will ruin the fishing for anyone behind for hours. Still, it seems worth the risk, especially if you can head up there on a weekday.
It's the sort of stream that keeps us exploring. I can't wait to go back.
Last week I bought a season NY State license, so it freed me to do something I've been meaning to do for years, which is explore Harriman State Park. I've hiked it several times, perhaps 15 years ago, but never fished it. It's just over the border, and time-wise, it's about 1:45 from Trenton, about the same as driving up to Van Campens. I'd heard there were some nice streams there. So I went online, and found really very little, except a 5 year old posting on a fly fishing board from a guy who claimed to live up there, who listed two of his favorite streams.
I found them both on a map. One really wasn't my style: it had road access its entire length. The other required a hike in, and ran through an isolated valley. Perfect! It had the added benefit of being in the far south of the park, making it even closer. Yeah! So today, after my appointment in Princeton this morning, I headed up 206 instead of coming home, and found myself at the trailhead around 1.
The stream was steep, and held a fair amount of water. I walked in about 30 minutes, then started to fish the pocket water. It reminded me of T Brook, only with about twice the flow.
Unfortunately, no fish. I tried a bunch of flies... started with a Cahill. Switched to a BHPT. After about an hour I landed a 3" green dace. An hour later, I picked an inchworm off my hat, and switched to an inchworm dry fly. But nothing.
I was about 3 hours in, with still only the dace in the credit column. I was thinking of giving up, when I came to the junction of a major trib... the junction pool didn't look like much, but just above the junction, the gradient of the main stem eased noticeably. I tossed the inchworm into the very first pocket above the junction, and was stunned when a feisty, 10" brown trout slammed the fly. I was actually startled by how strong he was. He pulled upstream about 20 feet, and I gave line for fear he'd break my 6x tippet. Very cool. This trout wasn't a giant, but would count as a big fish on any of NJ streams I normally frequent.
(Below: The first fish. You can see the inchworm fly in his mouth)
Why the steam below the trib didn't seem to hold any trout, I don't know. Perhaps it floods too frequently. All I know is it started to act like a lovely trout stream as soon as I got above it. (Below, the stream, just above where I caught the first fish)
It didn't take long for me to take a second fish... this one another strong, wild brown trout. This turned out to be a solid, fat 12". He also slammed the inchworm. He was holding in the quiet water, just right of the medium sized round rock in the middle/left of the photo.
I then tried to work may way up the slow pool you see in the photo, and around the bend. The inchworm was now waterlogged, kept sinking, and snagging bottom. So I spent about half an hour trying not to spook fish as I slowly waded in to free my fly, cast again, snagged again. All the movement killed the fishing. So I changed to a #14 parachute adams, which I figured would float reliably.
After making my way up to the next big pool, I took an even LARGER fish, a good 13", on the adams. When he felt the hook, he shot into the air about 3', then spun around the pool at a high rate of speed until he exhausted himself. On my light little 4 weight, it was all I could do to keep him under control and away from some snags.
Once I released him, I farted around this pool for a while, trying long casts, double hauling my little rod (which is NOT its preferred casting mode). However, the water was so still that any movement towards the back was sure to spook any fish waiting for me. I missed one strike from what flashed like another big fish, then caught a little pumkinseed. Then things seemed to go dead.
According to the topo map, there's probably another mile of good water, but the shadows were getting long. I reeled up, and started to hike back to the car. I saw some rising fish in a large pool close to the parking lot, where the gradient had eased again. I hovered for about two minutes, watching the water, and debating whether to give them a shot. Had I seen another rise, I might have been tempted, but it went quiet for the moment. I decided it was getting too late, and hurried on to the trailhead parking lot.
It was 6:05 by the time I stripped off my gear and started the car.
All in all, while it started slowly, it ended totally satisfactorily. Next time, I'll hike right above the junction, and start fishing from there. Judging from my sample, the fish in this stream are much larger than any wild trout stream I know in NJ. Definitely worth a return visit. Of course, it's also the sort of water where you'll be miserable if you're fishing behind anyone. One fisherman, even a good one, will ruin the fishing for anyone behind for hours. Still, it seems worth the risk, especially if you can head up there on a weekday.
It's the sort of stream that keeps us exploring. I can't wait to go back.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Hard Work
Fishing trip this weekend turned out to be hard work. My annual pilgrimage to Shenandoah didn't work out this year, so we decided to hit a couple of wild trout streams in the Catskills.
Saturday, Dan and I hopped in the car at 7 AM and reached the Vernooy Falls trailhead a little after 10. It's 1.8 miles and 700 vertical feet up to the falls, which we accomplished with little fuss. Moving up and downstream is another matter. There's really no trail, so you're bushwhacking through a pretty steep gorge. (Note: I wasn't in a photographing mood, so these photos were taken off the net).
The tone for the weekend was set in the first half hour when a largish rock give way as Dan descended into the riverbed. He clattered down (hard) and snapped the tip off his rod. Fortunately, he wasn't hurt, just shaken, and ultimately sore, but it cast a pall over the activities.
Of course, catching a few dozen wild brook trout might have changed our mood, but it wasn't to be. Surprising to me, we each caught only one fish. It wasn't for lack of trying... below the falls, the habitat seemed a little marginal (pretty shallow), but above the falls, which we explored in the afternoon, the habitat seemed superb. There were certainly plenty of flies on the water. I saw caddis, cahills, blue quills, and hendricksons, and tried them all at different times during the day. I fished on the surface, and nymphed. I saw only one rise, and had only three strikes all day. These were all in the same structure (a moderate pool below the falls). The strikes were little brookies nipping at my nymph, and I managed to land one of them. 10 minutes later, Dan took another carbon-copy fish in the same structure using a parachute adams. That was it.
I frankly don't understand it. Either these fish are unbelievably spooky, or there just weren't very many of them. I would think it's the latter. Hard to believe they would have been THAT spooky, as the water was fairly high, and turbulent, so I would have thought it would have covered us pretty well. Also, on streams with spooky fish, you can usually SEE them running away from you, at least occasionally. Certainly, in 5 hours, if it was a matter of spookiness, I'd have expected to see more fish signs. But I didn't see a single spooked fish.
After a night in the EconoLodge in Monticello, we hit the Neversink Gorge Unique area on Sunday. This is a 2.5 mile walk, descending about 750 vertical feet.
Talk about a constrast! Here the Neversink is about 150 feet wide. The water was a lot higher than shown in this photo... where we started fishing, the water averaged about knee deep, with slots and runs anywhere from 3 to 6 foot in depth. STRONG current. The kind of place where you needed a wading staff to get anywhere, and where you fear for your life if you slip on the irregular, bouldery bottom. I've waded in one or two tougher places (at least the rocks here weren't particularly slick), but not many, and not recently.
Two twenty-something fishermen showed up on the opposite bank soon after we started. They crossed over to talk (oh, to be 25 years old again! Now that I'm 50-something, I wouldn't dream of crossing the stream where they did). One of the guys pulled out 3 fish from the deeper slots in the middle of the stream, as I watched his slow approach. When they finally arrived, we got into a nice conversation. They seemed to be classic trout bums (You fish here often? Yeah, this is my third time on the stream this week). They checked out my nymph rig, and opined I needed heavier flies, and suggested going to larger sizes. The guy who'd caught all the fish pulled out 3 different nymphs from his fly box which he handed me, and swore would fix me up.
They moved on, picking up another fish in the next pocket, and were soon gone. These were the only other human beings we saw all day on what is a superb, if challenging, trout stream. If it were more accessible, I suggest we'd have seen a couple of dozen fishermen on a typical stretch of a Catskill Stream of this quality on a beautiful Sunday in mid May. It was glorious to be alone there.
I had NO luck at all with their flies. I'm usually a very good nympher (though I rarely fish such a large stream), I lost two of his flies (which were really heavy!) in the second slot I fished, as they jammed into the bottom of a slot too deep for me to retrieve. They had recommended tungsten bead heads, which are super heavy but I don't carry in my box (they're useless on small streams). I suspect my nymphs just weren't getting deep enough fast enough. After 3 hours, I was still fishless.
In desperation I changed to a full sinking line, and tied on a zoo cougar, my favorite streamer, which is a yellow sculpin pattern with a lot of flash. That turned out to be inspired, as I was immediately rewarded with a strike, and several chasers. It was also great fun double-hauling the line to reach the far bank, 70 feet from where I was standing. So at least I was entertained, and ultimately, after several more short strikes, managed to land a fat, 14" brookie which slammed the cougar as it flashed past his holding spot, just in front of a boulder.
So at least I wasn't skunked.
This is the kind of stream that rewards experience. I suspect next time (armed with a larger supply of heavy nymphs, and mentally prepared for the wading), I'd do OK.
The walk out was a long 2.5 miles and 750 foot climb. Mosquitos were making it a slow torture. I didn't want to goop with up DEET, since I figured I'd be in the car shortly. Instead, I suffered.
This weekend was hard work.
Saturday, Dan and I hopped in the car at 7 AM and reached the Vernooy Falls trailhead a little after 10. It's 1.8 miles and 700 vertical feet up to the falls, which we accomplished with little fuss. Moving up and downstream is another matter. There's really no trail, so you're bushwhacking through a pretty steep gorge. (Note: I wasn't in a photographing mood, so these photos were taken off the net).
The tone for the weekend was set in the first half hour when a largish rock give way as Dan descended into the riverbed. He clattered down (hard) and snapped the tip off his rod. Fortunately, he wasn't hurt, just shaken, and ultimately sore, but it cast a pall over the activities.
Of course, catching a few dozen wild brook trout might have changed our mood, but it wasn't to be. Surprising to me, we each caught only one fish. It wasn't for lack of trying... below the falls, the habitat seemed a little marginal (pretty shallow), but above the falls, which we explored in the afternoon, the habitat seemed superb. There were certainly plenty of flies on the water. I saw caddis, cahills, blue quills, and hendricksons, and tried them all at different times during the day. I fished on the surface, and nymphed. I saw only one rise, and had only three strikes all day. These were all in the same structure (a moderate pool below the falls). The strikes were little brookies nipping at my nymph, and I managed to land one of them. 10 minutes later, Dan took another carbon-copy fish in the same structure using a parachute adams. That was it.
I frankly don't understand it. Either these fish are unbelievably spooky, or there just weren't very many of them. I would think it's the latter. Hard to believe they would have been THAT spooky, as the water was fairly high, and turbulent, so I would have thought it would have covered us pretty well. Also, on streams with spooky fish, you can usually SEE them running away from you, at least occasionally. Certainly, in 5 hours, if it was a matter of spookiness, I'd have expected to see more fish signs. But I didn't see a single spooked fish.
After a night in the EconoLodge in Monticello, we hit the Neversink Gorge Unique area on Sunday. This is a 2.5 mile walk, descending about 750 vertical feet.
Talk about a constrast! Here the Neversink is about 150 feet wide. The water was a lot higher than shown in this photo... where we started fishing, the water averaged about knee deep, with slots and runs anywhere from 3 to 6 foot in depth. STRONG current. The kind of place where you needed a wading staff to get anywhere, and where you fear for your life if you slip on the irregular, bouldery bottom. I've waded in one or two tougher places (at least the rocks here weren't particularly slick), but not many, and not recently.
Two twenty-something fishermen showed up on the opposite bank soon after we started. They crossed over to talk (oh, to be 25 years old again! Now that I'm 50-something, I wouldn't dream of crossing the stream where they did). One of the guys pulled out 3 fish from the deeper slots in the middle of the stream, as I watched his slow approach. When they finally arrived, we got into a nice conversation. They seemed to be classic trout bums (You fish here often? Yeah, this is my third time on the stream this week). They checked out my nymph rig, and opined I needed heavier flies, and suggested going to larger sizes. The guy who'd caught all the fish pulled out 3 different nymphs from his fly box which he handed me, and swore would fix me up.
They moved on, picking up another fish in the next pocket, and were soon gone. These were the only other human beings we saw all day on what is a superb, if challenging, trout stream. If it were more accessible, I suggest we'd have seen a couple of dozen fishermen on a typical stretch of a Catskill Stream of this quality on a beautiful Sunday in mid May. It was glorious to be alone there.
I had NO luck at all with their flies. I'm usually a very good nympher (though I rarely fish such a large stream), I lost two of his flies (which were really heavy!) in the second slot I fished, as they jammed into the bottom of a slot too deep for me to retrieve. They had recommended tungsten bead heads, which are super heavy but I don't carry in my box (they're useless on small streams). I suspect my nymphs just weren't getting deep enough fast enough. After 3 hours, I was still fishless.
In desperation I changed to a full sinking line, and tied on a zoo cougar, my favorite streamer, which is a yellow sculpin pattern with a lot of flash. That turned out to be inspired, as I was immediately rewarded with a strike, and several chasers. It was also great fun double-hauling the line to reach the far bank, 70 feet from where I was standing. So at least I was entertained, and ultimately, after several more short strikes, managed to land a fat, 14" brookie which slammed the cougar as it flashed past his holding spot, just in front of a boulder.
So at least I wasn't skunked.
This is the kind of stream that rewards experience. I suspect next time (armed with a larger supply of heavy nymphs, and mentally prepared for the wading), I'd do OK.
The walk out was a long 2.5 miles and 750 foot climb. Mosquitos were making it a slow torture. I didn't want to goop with up DEET, since I figured I'd be in the car shortly. Instead, I suffered.
This weekend was hard work.
Monday, May 10, 2010
Mother's Day
My wife was committed all day (church, then work), so we celebrated Saturday... flowers and husband-cooked dinner with a nice bottle of wine. So Sunday, Mother's Day, I was free to fish.
Arrived at the "local" brook trout stream around 12:30. The weather certainly didn't seem auspicious. Barely 50 degrees, and windy.
Hoped that the fish would still rise to a dry fly. Tied on the same #18 adams parachute I'd had success with a couple of weeks earlier.
The first structure was a nice deep pool... large for this stream. No joy. Decided to try one more structure before abandoning hope for the adams.
Next structure was not so deep... mid-calf instead of over-the-knee. And a nice fish took my fly on the second drift.
This established the pattern for the next two hours. It was challenging in that the structure and presentation had to be just right: large enough, but not too shallow, not too deep, with a slow current. You needed pretty much a perfect, dead drift through the feeding lane. Get all the ingredients right, however, and a nice fish would rise. Typically 8-9", which is a more than decent size for this stream.
Fish of the day came from an overhanging boulder. My first drift flashed a big fish, but microdrag caused him to miss the take. While I had little confidence that he'd rise again, I waited a minute or so, then shortlined a few "prefect" drifts over the spot where he'd risen. It was satisfying when he slammed the third drift. Seemed to do a 180 degree spin as he shot out from underneath his boulder, flew a couple of inches into the air, and splashed onto his back before diving back to the depths. Nice strong pull on my line. A fat 12" fish!
Altogether, about a dozen fish in two hours. Actually the take rate seemed to increase over time, as the sun sneaked out and the warming water encouraged the fish to be even more active.
I'd had to change flies because a fish had chewed the hackle off my original fly. My knot on my new fly gave way when I pulled the nose of a fat 10" brookie out of the water. I took this as a sign, and reeled up. Once I feel I've "figured it out", I don't need to keep catching.
I changed into hiking shoes, and went for a delightful walk for the next 90 minutes, with nice steep trails, and lovely views of the S Branch valley.
Home by 5 PM. A perfect "Mother's Day."
Arrived at the "local" brook trout stream around 12:30. The weather certainly didn't seem auspicious. Barely 50 degrees, and windy.
Hoped that the fish would still rise to a dry fly. Tied on the same #18 adams parachute I'd had success with a couple of weeks earlier.
The first structure was a nice deep pool... large for this stream. No joy. Decided to try one more structure before abandoning hope for the adams.
Next structure was not so deep... mid-calf instead of over-the-knee. And a nice fish took my fly on the second drift.
This established the pattern for the next two hours. It was challenging in that the structure and presentation had to be just right: large enough, but not too shallow, not too deep, with a slow current. You needed pretty much a perfect, dead drift through the feeding lane. Get all the ingredients right, however, and a nice fish would rise. Typically 8-9", which is a more than decent size for this stream.
Fish of the day came from an overhanging boulder. My first drift flashed a big fish, but microdrag caused him to miss the take. While I had little confidence that he'd rise again, I waited a minute or so, then shortlined a few "prefect" drifts over the spot where he'd risen. It was satisfying when he slammed the third drift. Seemed to do a 180 degree spin as he shot out from underneath his boulder, flew a couple of inches into the air, and splashed onto his back before diving back to the depths. Nice strong pull on my line. A fat 12" fish!
Altogether, about a dozen fish in two hours. Actually the take rate seemed to increase over time, as the sun sneaked out and the warming water encouraged the fish to be even more active.
I'd had to change flies because a fish had chewed the hackle off my original fly. My knot on my new fly gave way when I pulled the nose of a fat 10" brookie out of the water. I took this as a sign, and reeled up. Once I feel I've "figured it out", I don't need to keep catching.
I changed into hiking shoes, and went for a delightful walk for the next 90 minutes, with nice steep trails, and lovely views of the S Branch valley.
Home by 5 PM. A perfect "Mother's Day."
Saturday, April 24, 2010
Dry Run
It's been one of the nicest springs I can ever remember in NJ. It seems every day is in the upper '60s, with sun and low humidity, except for the occasional rainy day, which keeps the water levels up. Magnificent! It's a pleasure to be only partially employed at times like this.
Next Tuesday, I'm taking out two fisherfolk who "won" my services at charity silent auction. The goal is to teach them small stream fishing. I decided to check out (once again) my favorite stream, so I could work out flies and check out current conditions.
It turned out to be a somewhat challenging day, with gusty winds originating upstream making casting with my light rod adventurous at times. Fly selection also turned out to be slightly tricky, only in that the smaller fish seemed to be locked into some sort of tiny midge, which I couldn't see. Fortunately, the bigger fish seemed happy to rise to my parachute adams.
I caught this lovely brown on the first structure I fished (note: all fish were successfully released after photography).
The last fish of the day was this "giant" rainbow. Don't know if it's obvious, but this is a genuine 12" fish, which is enormous for these streams. He was holding in the deep trough between the two boulders...
Next Tuesday, I'm taking out two fisherfolk who "won" my services at charity silent auction. The goal is to teach them small stream fishing. I decided to check out (once again) my favorite stream, so I could work out flies and check out current conditions.
It turned out to be a somewhat challenging day, with gusty winds originating upstream making casting with my light rod adventurous at times. Fly selection also turned out to be slightly tricky, only in that the smaller fish seemed to be locked into some sort of tiny midge, which I couldn't see. Fortunately, the bigger fish seemed happy to rise to my parachute adams.
I caught this lovely brown on the first structure I fished (note: all fish were successfully released after photography).
The last fish of the day was this "giant" rainbow. Don't know if it's obvious, but this is a genuine 12" fish, which is enormous for these streams. He was holding in the deep trough between the two boulders...
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Perfect Day Fishing
Today was just about the perfect day for fishing.
Arrived at my closest brook trout stream around 11 AM, geared up, and saw two fish rising as I approached the first pocket.
Tied on a Hendrickson dry, #16, and caught a small fish on the 3rd cast. However, two other fish "refused" my fly (i.e. rose but didn't take). Spent the next 40 minutes or so trying to figure out why the refusals. To make a long story short, after about 6 fly changes, and more than a dozen refusals, I concluded they just wanted something really small. I tied on a #20 parachute adams, and became convinced it was what they wanted when a nice fish, that had refused a larger fly, rose again and this time swallowed the smaller one. The #20 adams stayed on the rest of the day.
The fish below is fairly typical... I caught one or two larger, 5 or 6 of this size, and quite a few smaller over the next two hours.
Basically, it was a day when EVERY structure with enough depth provided a fish. You wouldn't get a strike on every cast... but a good drift over anything deep enough, with slow current, would offer up a rise. Usually on the first cast, though sometimes it would take two or three. Once I got the fly size right, the only reason I would miss a fish would be if my presentation had too much drag. Then I might raise a fish and get a refusal. Once the fish came up it was hard to get him to come up again, though not impossible, and I probably saved half the chances I initially blew through better line control and persistent casts over the holding spot.
As you can see in the photo below, the water levels were perfect, and essentially all of these pockets were fishable.
There was so much activity, there seemed no need to count. I'm guessing I caught about 20 fish in two hours or so. You can see below that my fly was well and truly gnawed.
Really, it was a spectacular day out.
Arrived at my closest brook trout stream around 11 AM, geared up, and saw two fish rising as I approached the first pocket.
Tied on a Hendrickson dry, #16, and caught a small fish on the 3rd cast. However, two other fish "refused" my fly (i.e. rose but didn't take). Spent the next 40 minutes or so trying to figure out why the refusals. To make a long story short, after about 6 fly changes, and more than a dozen refusals, I concluded they just wanted something really small. I tied on a #20 parachute adams, and became convinced it was what they wanted when a nice fish, that had refused a larger fly, rose again and this time swallowed the smaller one. The #20 adams stayed on the rest of the day.
The fish below is fairly typical... I caught one or two larger, 5 or 6 of this size, and quite a few smaller over the next two hours.
Basically, it was a day when EVERY structure with enough depth provided a fish. You wouldn't get a strike on every cast... but a good drift over anything deep enough, with slow current, would offer up a rise. Usually on the first cast, though sometimes it would take two or three. Once I got the fly size right, the only reason I would miss a fish would be if my presentation had too much drag. Then I might raise a fish and get a refusal. Once the fish came up it was hard to get him to come up again, though not impossible, and I probably saved half the chances I initially blew through better line control and persistent casts over the holding spot.
As you can see in the photo below, the water levels were perfect, and essentially all of these pockets were fishable.
There was so much activity, there seemed no need to count. I'm guessing I caught about 20 fish in two hours or so. You can see below that my fly was well and truly gnawed.
Really, it was a spectacular day out.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)












